[ale] Re: Vote Today - Message from Marie

[Jeff Hubbs]

> > Hopefully they were not the little
> > CMOS batteries, though I have replaced only one of this type in my entire
> > life.  2) the vote is recorded in three places, one including flash memory.
> > OK, so any mistake is now multiplied times 3.  I get it.  Redundancy = =
> > accuracy  3) In reply to my asking if I could see the code, I was told that
> > the code was audited by Kennesaw State University to comply with Federal and
> > State specs.  
> 
> I am singularly unimpressed by such a statement.  I'd buy a peer review
> with published names and qualifications.

On second thought, maybe I wouldn't.  Without any assurance that the
reviewed code is the running code, what good is this knowledge?

I'm reminded of the notion presented in the film "MINORITY REPORT" in
which the names of murderers and their victims as determined by the
three "pre-cogs" are engraved into wooden balls that are laser-machined
on the spot; the proposed notion was that each wooden ball would be
necessarily unique, although how that property was utilized to prevent
corruption of the system wasn't explained or examined.  

- Jeff


---
This message has been sent through the ALE general discussion list.
See http://www.ale.org/mailing-lists.shtml for more info. Problems should be 
sent to listmaster at ale dot org.